Why what people say often misses what people actually do.
When marketers ask customers, “Why did you buy this?” they expect a rational response: reasoned logic, clear motives, conscious decisions.
But the human brain often decides before the conscious mind has even formed a sentence.
That means what people say and what they do might not align.
If we rely only on surveys, interviews, and self-reports, we risk building marketing strategies on shaky foundations.
Let’s explore why, and what you should do about it.
The Limits of Self‑Report Methods
Survey-based research has been a cornerstone of marketing for decades.
But it relies on people’s ability and willingness to articulate the motives behind their behavior. And that’s a big “if.”
-
Response biases like social desirability or acquiescence mean respondents might tell you what they should say, not what they truly feel.
-
Studies show that self-reported intentions and actual behavior often diverge, especially when unconscious drivers are in play.
-
A comprehensive review found that self-report methods struggle to capture the temporal, emotional and attentional processes that shape purchase behavior (Sánchez‑Fernández et al., 2021).
In short: asking is easy; capturing what matters is hard.
Decision‑Making Happens Beneath Awareness
The brain isn’t waiting for us to reflect and rationalize.
It uses heuristics, shortcuts, and automatic responses to navigate overload.
One review explains that neuroscientific tools can measure emotional and attentional responses in real time: something self‑report simply cannot (Balconi & Sansone, 2021).
For instance:
-
When exposed to marketing stimuli, neural responses often precede conscious intention (Hsu, 2015).
-
Memory distortion biases such as “choice‐supportive bias” mean people remember their decisions more favorably than reality (Wikipedia, n.d.).
Bottom line: by the time a person explains why they bought something, the true driver may already be recast by memory or narrative.
Why Marketing Built Only on What People Say Can Miss the Mark
-
Feature‑based messaging (“our product has X functionality”) assumes people consciously evaluate attributes, but studies suggest emotion, familiarity and context often dominate (Pirouz, 2004).
-
Market research that doesn’t account for attention, memory encoding or emotion may solve for the wrong problem.
-
Brands that listen to what people say risk missing why people act—and miss the opportunity to influence how they act.
What You Can Do Instead
Making your approach more reliable doesn’t require a neuro lab. It requires a smarter framework:
-
Combine self‑reports with behaviour & cues: track how people interact, not just what they say.
-
Ask fewer questions, design fewer steps. The easier the journey, the better the brain responds.
-
Use design, emotion, memory and attention as part of your strategy. Behavior science shows these are stronger levers than logic alone.
-
Regularly test, iterate and observe—because what people do often reveals more than what they say.
Final Thoughts
Consumer awareness is real, but limited.
Humans are not always able to articulate why they choose what they do.
And when marketers rely only on what people say, they risk missing the richest opportunities.
InPsychful Marketing helps you go beyond the report card… to the underlying behavior.
Because when you design for how people really decide, you convert not just more—but smarter.
References
Balconi, M., & Sansone, M. (2021). Neuroscience and consumer behavior: Where to now? Frontiers in Psychology, 12, Article 705850. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.705850
Hsu, M. (2015). The neuroscience of consumer choice. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 14(1), 1‑7. https://doi.org/10.1002/cb.2181
Pirouz, D. (2004). The neuroscience of consumer decision‑making. MPRA Paper No. 2181. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2181
Sánchez‑Fernández, J., Casado‑Aranda, L.‑A., & Bastidas‑Manzano, A.‑B. (2021). Consumer neuroscience techniques in advertising research: A bibliometric citation analysis. Sustainability, 13(3), 1589. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13031589